0 items in cart

FREE SHIPPING EVERY DAY Order within 21 hours and 52 minutes to ship Tuesday

Page Content Begins Here
Sort Results
FILTERS (3) 36 FOUND Reset Done
Coming Soon
Glove Coach TRY OUR GLOVE COACH Answer a few simple questions to find your perfect glove.

First Base Extra Stiff Stiff

36 FOUND

First Base Extra Stiff Stiff CLEAR ALL
Popular Popular, click to sort ascending Latest Latest, click to sort descending Avg. Rating Avg. Rating, click to sort descending Savings Savings, click to sort descending $: Low to High $: Low to High, click to sort ascending $: High to Low $: High to Low, click to sort descending
Angled view of two tan and black baseball mitts, one open showing the Rawlings Heart of the Hide embossed palm.
Rawlings Heart of the Hide 13" Baseball First Base Mitt: PRORDCT-10C $329.99
Angled view of two white Mizuno softball mitts with gray lacing, showing a deep pocket and X-laced web.
Mizuno MVP Prime 13" Fastpitch Softball First Base Mitt: GXF50FPW2 $129.95
Angled front view of a brown first base mitt with embossed A2000 logo, two-tone lacing, and a single post web.
Wilson A2000 AC4 Amanda Chidester 12.5" Fastpitch First Base Mitt: WBW101017125 $139.95 - $179.95 Price was: $329.95
Angled view of two black baseball mitts with gold stitching, a Mizuno logo in the pocket, and a gold M on the wrist.
Mizuno MVP Prime 12.5" Baseball First Base Mitt: GXF50PB4 $129.95
Angled front view of a gray fastpitch mitt with A2000 and Wilson logos, featuring a red W on the white palm.
Wilson A2000 SuperSkin FP1B 12.50" Fastpitch Softball First Base Mitt: WBW100219125 $239.95 Price was: $329.95 Used from $199.95
Angled view of a tan baseball first base mitt showing its open palm with Rawlings Heart of the Hide logo and a red Rawlings patch.
Rawlings Heart of the Hide 13" Baseball First Base Mitt: PROTDCTT $329.99
Three-quarter view of a black and gray baseball mitt with orange lacing, a black web, and A2000 and Wilson logos.
Wilson A2000 SuperSkin 1620 12.5" Baseball First Base Mitt: WBW100119125 $239.95 - $299.95 Price was: $329.95 Used from $194.95
Angled open view of a tan baseball first base mitt with a Shoeless Joe logo, intricate lacing, and a deep pocket.
Shoeless Joe Professional 12" Baseball First Base Mitt: 1200FB $199.95 Only at
Angled view of a brown baseball first base mitt with Shoeless Joe logo, Tennessee Trapper text, and prominent lacing.
Shoeless Joe Professional 13" Baseball First Base Mitt: 1300FBTT $199.95 Only at
Front and back views of a hot pink and mint green leather first base mitt with pink laces, featuring the "Rawlings" and "HEART of the HIDE" logos.
Rawlings Heart of the Hide ColorSync 10.0 13" First Base Mitt: PRORDCT-10BEM $329.99
Front and back view of a black first base mitt with teal laces and pink stitching, displaying the A2K and Wilson brand names and a cyan W logo.
Wilson A2K 1679CF 12.5" Spring Collection Baseball First Base Mitt: WBW102751125 $299.95 Price was: $449.95 Used from $254.95
Angled view of a tan baseball first base mitt with A2000 embossed on the palm and a Wilson logo on the back.
Wilson A2000 Classic 1679 12.5" Baseball First Base Mitt: WBW102097125 $329.95 Used from $279.95
Angled view of two teal Marucci Ascension Series baseball first base mitts with blue lacing, one showing the palm, the other the back.
Marucci Ascension12.75" Baseball First Base Mitt: MFG4AS38S1 $209.95
Angled view of a white first base mitt with brown lacing, Mizuno logo, and PRO SELECT text on the thumb.
Mizuno Pro Select 12.50" Fastpitch Softball First Base Mitt: GPSF-30 $299.95
Front view of a mint green and pink baseball mitt with gold Rawlings logo, gold trim, and white lacing.
Rawlings Heart of the Hide Mint Condition 13" Baseball First Base Mitt: PRORDCT-10MP $329.99 Only at
Angled view of a white and blue fastpitch softball mitt with an open palm and pink Easton Professional Collection branding.
Easton Professional Collection 13" Fastpitch Softball First Base Mitt: PCFP13-10WCB $269.99
Angled front view of a tan baseball first base mitt with Rawlings branding, a single post web, and intricate lacing.
Rawlings Pro Preferred 13" Baseball First Base Mitt: PROSBH3 $419.99
Angled view of two black baseball first base mitts, one showing A2000 embossing, the other with a yellow Wilson logo.
Wilson A2000 Classic 1679 12.5" Baseball First Base Mitt: WBW102095125 $329.95 Used from $279.95
Front and side view of a Wilson A2000 first base mitt featuring a tan leather palm, blue textured shell, red laces, and a yellow logo.
Wilson A2000 1677 SuperSkin Summer Collection 12.5" Baseball First Base Mitt: WBW104605125 $349.95 Used from $299.95
Front view of a bright blue catcher's mitt with pink accents, featuring the "A2000" logo on the palm and the Wilson "W" logo on the side.
Wilson A2000 1612 Love the Moment 12'' Baseball First Base Mitt: WBW1048312 $329.95
Angled front view of a purple baseball first base mitt with teal lacing, yellow trim, and an embossed A2000 logo.
Wilson A2000 SuperSnakeSkin 1612 Spring Collection 12" Baseball First Base Mitt: WBW10414012 $329.95 Used from $279.95
Open view of a pink first base mitt with blue lacing, a Rawlings logo, and a Heart of the Hide emblem on the palm.
Rawlings Heart of the Hide 12.25" Baseball First Base Mitt: PRORDCTU-10PCB $329.99
Front view of a pink fastpitch softball mitt with teal lacing, A2000 and Wilson logos, and a teal web.
Wilson A2000 FP1B 12.5" Winter Collection Fastpitch Softball First Base Mitt: WBW103949125 $329.95 Used from $279.95
Front view of a blonde Wilson A2000 first base mitt featuring light blue laces, red accents, and prominent A2000 and Wilson logos.
Wilson A2000 1677 12.5" Spring Collection Baseball First Base Mitt: WBW102753125 $299.95 Price was: $349.95 Used from $254.95
Load More Products

Put Our Expertise to Work

We know gloves - and we’re here to help you find the perfect fit. Get the right one for your game with these resources:

Sizing Guide

Determine the right size glove for you or your player

Glove Coach

Get just-for-you glove recommendations

Resource Guide

Find helpful information written by our roster of Experts

1-866-321-4568

support@justgloves.com

Show Comparison
4.9 Star Rating, Google Customer Reviews