Used Catcher's Mitts

Anyone who has ever played behind the plate knows two universal truths: quality catcher's mitts are an investment, and breaking in a brand-new one takes serious work. The collection of Used Catcher's Mitts at JustGloves solves both problems at once. Whether you are a competitive player looking for a pro-stock backup, a parent outfitting a growing youth catcher, or a coach stocking up on team gear, our pre-owned and previously played-with catcher's mitts deliver top-tier performance at a fraction of the retail price.

Why Buy a Pre-Owned Catcher's Mitt from JustGloves?

• Skip the Brutal Break-In: Stiff leather and thick padding make new catcher’s mitts notorious for taking weeks—or even months—to get game-ready. Our used mitts already have the initial stiffness worked out, meaning you can take them straight from the box to the bullpen.
• Pro-Level Leather on a Budget: Step up to elite series like the Rawlings Heart of the Hide, Wilson A2000, All-Star Pro Elite, or Mizuno Pro without paying full retail price.
• Inspected by Glove Experts: We don't put just anything on our shelves. Every used catcher's mitt goes through a strict multi-point inspection by the JustGloves team. We verify that the laces are intact, the pocket is structurally sound, and the heel and thumb padding still offer the protection you need behind the dish.
• 30-Day Guarantee & Free Shipping: Every used catcher's mitt is backed by the JustGloves free, fast shipping promise and our customer-first 30-day return policy.