Skip to main content Skip to footer site map
0 items in cart

FREE SHIPPING EVERY DAY

Order within 38 hours and 10 minutes to ship Monday
Page Content

06/07/2021

Best Catcher's Mitts

Finding the right catcher’s mitt can be a challenging task for even the most veteran shoppers. With so many different mitts to choose from, it’s essential to know what to look for when shopping for the best catcher’s mitt. 

For starters, it’s important to know the quality of leather used to build a mitt is directly correlated to the price tag. Exceptions such as closeout catcher’s mitts do exist. But for the most part, the more you are willing to spend, the better your baseball catcher’s leather quality will be. 

We have picked out three of the best catcher’s mitts, along with the top mitt manufacturers to shop from. As always, if you have any questions or need assistance while shopping, please don’t hesitate to reach out to our friendly team of Glove Experts. 

Shop Catcher’s Mitts Under $100

What Size Mitt Does My Baseball Catcher Need?

Before we dive into our favorite catcher’s mitts, we need to make sure that you know what you’re looking for. 

When sizing a catcher’s mitt for a baseball catcher, you’ll want to use the following chart as a general guideline. Mitt size will vary by player. This chart is merely a means to get you in the right ballpark regarding your catcher’s mitt.

AGE CATCHER FIRST BASE SECOND BASE/
SHORT STOP
THIRD BASE PITCHER OUTFIELD
Under 7 29.5 - 30" 11.5" 8 - 10.5" 8 - 10.5" 8 - 10.5" 9 - 10.5"
8 - 10 30 - 31" 11.5 - 12" 10.5 - 11.25" 10.5 - 11.5" 10.5 - 11.5" 10 - 12"
11 - 13 30 - 32.5" 11.5 - 12" 11 - 11.5" 11 - 11.75" 11.5 - 12" 11.75 - 12.75"
Over 14 32 - 34.5" 12 - 13" 11.25 - 11.5" 11.5 - 12" 11.5 - 12" 12 - 13"

How to Shop for a Baseball Catcher’s Mitt

It’s important to factor in all of the responsibilities of a baseball catcher when shopping for your next mitt. Beyond just receiving pitches, a catcher must control opposing baserunners, block pitches thrown in the dirt, and frame borderline pitches back into the strike zone. 

Shop for a smaller catcher’s mitt if you want to be more active behind the dish, develop a faster pop time, and have more control over your glove.

Shop for a larger catcher’s mitt if you want to provide a larger target for your pitcher and block more balls thrown in the dirt.

The 3 Best Baseball Catcher’s Mitts

Based on catcher’s mitt reviews, customer feedback, and expert analysis, we have compiled a list of the three best catcher’s mitts currently available at JustGloves

All Star Pro Elite 33.5” Baseball Catcher’s Mitt (CM3000SBT)

This is our highest-reviewed catcher’s mitt, and it’s easy to see why. Built from Japanese Tanned U.S. Steerhide leather, the Pro Elite offers a faster break-in time with a longer lifespan compared to market competition. It provides baseball catcher’s with a reinforced closed web that can hold up against the highest velocities. Given the size, cost, and effort required to break it in, we would only recommend this mitt for a high school or older catcher.

Enjoy these glove reviews of the All Star Pro Elite:

Pros: I love this mitt. No wonder so many pro players use this. You’ll be amazed at how soft it is. 

Cons: I prefer a conventional back to a Velcro strap.

Pros: This mitt is the best there is. Great leather, very comfortable, and amazing pop! I can’t wait till I start catching it in games this spring.  

Cons: NOTHING!!

Pros: This glove is gorgeous! So far I’ve had it for only a week now. Close to game ready but not quite. I have only caught a few bullpens, but it’s very close. Beautiful glove, greatest sound a glove could make and overall great quality.  

Cons: A bit pricey but worth every penny.

Wilson A2000 33" Catcher's Mitt (WTA20RB19CM33)

When talking about the “best gloves/mitts,” it’s nearly impossible to keep a Wilson A2000 off the list. This fan-favorite mitt is made from Pro Stock leather and is designed to fit a smaller hand. The Half Moon web consistently aligns the ball in the pocket to allow for fast transfers when throwing out baserunners. Lastly, you can expect this A2000 to last for multiple seasons due to the dual welting used in the construction of the mitt. Smaller-handed catchers that are serious about the game of baseball should definitely be in the market for this beauty from Wilson.

Enjoy these glove reviews of the Wilson A2000 33” Catcher’s Mitt:

Pros: Very nice stiff leather, deep pocket, snug fit. Great looking and well constructed mitt, Wilson leather is top-notch. Purchased for a 12-year old who out grew his last mitt. Player has fairly big hands already (size large in batting gloves), but likes the snug fit of this mitt as he breaks it in. He’s really happy with the look, feel and fit.

Cons: Not a con, but it will take quite a bit of work to break in and become game playable. Access to an iron mike pitching machine really helps.

Pros: Great mitt, good price, excellent delivery time. Worked it a couple days then my grandson started using it it in games, it was still a little stiff but worked great.

Cons: None

Rawlings Heart of the Hide R2G 33” Catcher’s Mitt (PRORCM33-23BC)

Much like the Wilson A2000 mentioned above, how could you have a glove list without a Rawlings Heart of the Hide? This 33-inch catcher’s mitt is made to be used by the game’s best players. This mitt will arrive 75% broken in to allow for near immediate use. The traditional Heart of the Hide leather comes from the top 5% of Rawlings’ leather hides, meaning that you’re buying the best of the best. Given its size and fit, we’d recommend this mitt to any middle school or high school baseball catcher.

Enjoy these glove reviews of the Rawlings Heart of the Hide R2G:

Pros: High quality, nice product! Fast shipping, and the glove came in nearly game ready. Spent a couple days playing catch and it was ready for game day. The sound of the ball hitting the glove is wicked!  

Cons: None

Pros: This glove is game ready with very minimal drops and with higher velo --- No drops. Love the finger pad that provides extra padding. Also you can mold this to your hand and even box it if you want. So far this has been the perfect alternative.  

Cons: The palm padding is very minimal compared to my old glove. I don’t know why this is, maybe because I bought it used, but it was in excellent condition.

Add Trusted Glove Prep to jumpstart your mitt break-in

Top Catcher’s Mitt Brands to Shop

Baseball manufacturers continue to produce new catcher’s mitts each year. It can be challenging to learn the pros and cons of each new release, but if you know the most reliable brands to shop then, you’ll start to get a sense of what to expect from your purchase. The following (in alphabetical order) are our customer’s favorite catcher’s mitt brands to shop from:

  • Shop Akadema Catcher’s Mitts
    Grab for a value mitt with Akadema. Typically around the $100 range, these mitts are made from genuine leather and provide outstanding performance for multiple seasons.
  • Shop All Star Catcher’s Mitts
    All Star makes a mean catcher’s mitt. All Star mitts are designed from the most durable leather for the most serious ballplayers.
  • Shop Nokona Catcher’s Mitts
    Nokona has built its business upon handcrafted, American-made leather gloves. Their catcher’s mitts are no exception.
  • Shop Rawlings Catcher’s Mitts
    Rawlings is the most popular brand of baseball glove used at the Major League level. The top catcher’s mitts made by Rawlings rival any other brand in the game.
  • Shop Wilson Catcher’s Mitts
    You can’t go wrong with Wilson. Whether you grab an A2000 or an A2K, Wilson never fails to deliver.

---

Only 30 players can be starting MLB catchers, but that doesn’t mean you can’t wear the best mitt. If you still need help finding a new catcher’s mitt, please don’t hesitate to reach out to us. You can contact our Glove Experts via phone (866-321-4568), email (experts@justgloves.com), or LIVE CHAT. 

We’re JustGloves, and we’re with you from Click to Catch!

You can compare a maximum of four items.
Please remove one item to add another.
Add up to 4 items to compare.
Compare (0 of 4) Show Comparison