Are you ready for the long days and late nights at the field this summer? There’s nothing better than getting together with the team, competing against the competition, and then going home with a win. A close second is that feeling when you get a new glove and play catch with it for the first time. Are you on the hunt for a new slow pitch glove? Check out the six gloves below (with one first base mitt) that we recommend as the top models for 2021. This list is based on reviews, feedback, and knowledge from our glove experts.
Let’s dive in.
Before we get into the features, pros, and cons of this Player Preferred series from Rawlings, let’s start with some of the reviews. The P140BPS is the highest rated slow pitch glove at JustGloves for the 2021 season, and at the time this article came out, there were 10+ five-star reviews. Plus, it’s under $100 dollars!
Review by UtiliCoach (Coach)
Pros: Great glove. I've had it for about 8 years. Durable lacing has barely needed adjusting. Nothing ever pops out of this basket. Contains softballs no matter how much spin/slice is on it.
Cons: The only con I can think of is that it feels a little silly when I play catch with my kid using his baseball. 14" is just too much glove for a baseball. For softball, it is a dream.
Review by Cathy (Player)
Pros: Semi broke-in leather glove at time of reception. I spent a few hours working the leather, put a ball in, and tied it off. Repeated the process a couple of times and voila, ready to use!
Cons: The lacing was a little too loose for my liking. Only took me 5 minutes to tighten up the fingers.
As you can see, the pros outweigh the cons and it’s not even close. And for the price, you really can’t go wrong. Other notable features of the 14 inch Rawlings Player Preferred Slow Pitch Glove include:
- Adjustable, Non-Slip Pull Strap Back
- Basket Web With Support Strap
- Break-In: 20% Player, 80% Factory
- Zero Shock Palm Padding For Impact Protection
Miken bats dominate diamonds and are one of the highest-rated slowpitch bats year after year. Miken gloves are no different. Specifically, this Player Series model in a 13 ½ inch size is a top choice right out of the box. With next to no break-in required, Miken claims this glove arrives with a 90% factory break-in. That feature, combined with an adjustable non-slip pull back strip, makes this option perfect for players in a time crunch who need a game-ready glove. Other notable features include:
- H-Web (A Great Choice For Infield & Outfield)
- Index Finger Pad For Comfort And Protection
- PORON XRD Palm Pad Reduces Ball Impact and Sting
Nokona gloves are hard to beat, especially when compared to this Nokona X2 Buckaroo. For over 75 years, Nokona has been perfecting the craft of glove making and this model highlights the time and effort that they truly put into each one of their handcrafted products.
The X2 Buckaroo is a utility model that can be used at nearly every position. The 13-inch size makes it an excellent option for both infield and outfield, while the fully closed web tends to be a personal preference of pitchers on the mound. When purchasing this high-performing, game-ready design, you’re guaranteed to get a glove made in the USA with only the highest quality leather. Notable features of this X2-1300 include:
- Nolera Composite Padding System Provides Unbeatable Protection
- Two (2) Year Manufacturer's Warranty
- Weight: Approx. 770 g
Before we move on and round out the top three, here’s our favorite review of the X2 Buckaroo from Nokona.
Review by Debbie (Other)
Pros: I purchased this glove for my boyfriend who plays Senior Softball. He's left handed. He did all the research and chose Nokona. When I gave him his glove he turned into a little boy playing with his ball and glove on the sofa. He decided he also wanted Nokona Oil to break-in and protect the leather. He is thrilled and he says his catching has improved. There are 7 Senior teams in his league and his team is now in lead with 7 wins and two losses. He did not have his glove during the two losses.
Shoeless Joe gloves are some of the most unique, unbeatable designs in the game today. The 1400HW is crafted with special-aged antique tobacco leather that provides the feel, style, and smell of gloves from the golden age. This is yet another slow pitch glove that arrives ready to play and requires minimal break-in if that’s what you prefer. If you’re an outfielder with large hands, the 14-inch size combined with the H-web makes this a top-notch option. Other features include:
- Hand Rubbed with Old Time Ingredients to Soften the Leather
- Individually Hand-Cut and Sewn
- Each Glove is Unique and Unstructured
High quality? Check. Utility option? Yep. Glorious? Absolutely.
You can use this A2000 model from Wilson in just about any position while playing slow pitch. The large 13” size with a single post web makes it easy to handle a softball regardless of whether you’re in the infield or outfield. The best part? Wilson’s SuperSkin helps lighten the glove, repel moisture, and is two times stronger than traditional leather. Other notable features include:
- Dri-Lex Wrist Lining Offers Ultra-Breathable, Moisture Wicking Material
- New Gap Welting For A Massive Catching Area
- Pro Stock Leather Provides Rugged Durability With An Unbeatable Feel
We couldn’t finish this list of the best slowpitch softball gloves without including a Mizuno mitt. The Franchise series is our favorite because it helps to elevate your game without breaking the bank. This 13-inch design with a fan-favorite H-web makes it a great design for both infielders and outfielders. It’s crafted out of Java leather that arrives pre-oiled for a supple feel. After one or two games of catch, this model should be ready to go. Other key features include:
- HiLo Lacing - Alternating Lace Pattern Retains Integrity Of Fully Laced Web With Greater Flexibility
- Ortholite Parashock Plus Palm Pad Reduces Sting & Deadens Ball Impact
- PowerLock Design With Velcro Wrist Strap
First Base Mitt: Nokona X2 Elite 13" First Base Mitt: X2-N70
Did you think we’d forget about you first basemen? Not a chance! While the price tag on this model would make some think twice, we promise it’s worth every penny. Not only are Nokona mitts made right here in the USA, but they are handcrafted with top grain stampede steerhide and kangaroo leather, which is pound for pound one of the toughest leathers in the world.
The X2 Elite series tends to be for the game’s most skilled, position-specific players and it arrives essentially game ready with minimal break-in required. Other key features of this first base mitt include:
- Two Year Manufacturer’s Warranty
- Conventional Open Back That Delivers A Classic-Style Look
There you have it. The ultimate list of the best slowpitch softball gloves for the 2021 season and beyond. Here at JustGloves, we love to equip players of all experience levels and hope that you consider us when making your next softball glove purchase. If you have any questions, we have glove experts available 24/7 via phone at 866-321-4568, email at email@example.com, or via live chat on our website. Don’t forget, we’re here for you from Click To Catch!