Finding the best catcher’s mitt can be a challenging task for even the most veteran baseball and softball players. With so many different mitts to choose from, it can oftentimes be essential to know what to look for when shopping.
For starters, you might begin your shopping experience by trying to learn which mitt has the best leather quality. Or you might try and look for a closeout glove that is available at a bargain price, while still being able to hold up over several seasons. But we also imagine that just the thought of having to dive through all of the different catcher's mitt reviews and product descriptions could stress you out!
Because of that, the Glove Experts at JustGloves curated a short list of baseball and fastpitch catcher mitts. We have mitts that are top quality. We have ones with excellent discounts! We have ones that might fly under the radar unless we brought them up to you. Let's dive in!
The Best Catcher's Mitts For Baseball & Fastpitch
Baseball
Fastpitch
Reviews For Top Baseball Catcher’s Mitts
1) All Star Pro Elite 33.5” Baseball Catcher’s Mitt (CM3000SBT)
This is our highest-reviewed catcher’s mitt, and it’s easy to see why. Built from Japanese Tanned U.S. Steerhide leather, the Pro Elite offers a long lifespan compared to the market competition. It provides baseball catchers with a reinforced closed web that can hold up against the highest velocities. Given the size, cost, and effort required to break it in, we would only recommend this mitt for a high school or older catcher.
Enjoy these glove reviews of the All-Star Pro Elite:
- "I love this mitt. No wonder so many pro players use this. You’ll be amazed at how soft it is."
- "This mitt is the best there is. Great leather, very comfortable, and amazing pop! I can’t wait till I start catching it in games this spring."
- "This glove is gorgeous! So far, I’ve had it for only a week now. Close to game-ready but not quite. I have only caught a few bullpens, but it’s very close. Beautiful glove, the greatest sound a glove could make, and overall great quality."
2) Wilson A2000 SuperSkin M1D 33.5" Baseball Catcher's Mitt (WBW100401335)
When talking about the “best mitts,” it’s nearly impossible to keep a Wilson A2000 off the list. This fan-favorite mitt is made from Pro Stock leather. The Half Moon web consistently aligns the ball in the pocket to allow for fast transfers when throwing out baserunners. Lastly, you can expect this A2000 to be lightweight for a 33.5" mitt. The SuperSkin backing is designed to be lighter in weight than regular leather (and even stronger than regular leather). Overall, this glove should be able to handle every task behind the dish!
Three more features of the Wilson A2000 33.5” Catcher’s Mitt:
- Comfort Pro Fit - Pro Lux Hand Lining Is Super Soft & The Comfort Sleeve Prevents Irritation On The Wrist
- M1D Pattern Provides A Deep Pocket On The Mitt
- Index Finger Pad On Shell Backing Improves Comfort & Protection
Reviews For Top Fastpitch Catcher's Mitts
1) All Star PHX Paige Halstead 34" Fastpitch Softball Catcher's Mitt (CMW-PHX-34)
Frequently Asked Catchers Mitt Questions
- What Size Mitt Does My Baseball Catcher Need?
When sizing a catcher’s mitt for a baseball catcher, you’ll want to use the following chart as a general guideline. Mitt size will vary by player. This chart is merely a means to get you in the right ballpark regarding your catcher’s mitt.
- How to Shop for a Baseball Catcher’s Mitt?
It’s important to factor in all of the responsibilities of a baseball catcher when shopping for your next mitt. Beyond just receiving pitches, a catcher must control opposing baserunners, block pitches thrown in the dirt, and frame borderline pitches back into the strike zone.
Shop for a smaller catcher’s mitt if you want to be more active behind the dish, develop a faster pop time, and have more control over your glove.
Shop for a larger catcher’s mitt if you want to provide a larger target for your pitcher and block more balls thrown in the dirt. - What Are The Top Catcher Brands To Shop?
Baseball manufacturers continue to produce new catcher’s mitts each year. It can be challenging to learn the pros and cons of each new release, but if you know the most reliable brands to shop then you’ll start to get a sense of what to expect from your purchase. The following (in alphabetical order) are our customers’ favorite catcher’s mitt brands to shop from:
Shop Akadema Catcher’s Mitts
Grab a value mitt with Akadema. Typically around the $100 range, these mitts are made from genuine leather and provide outstanding performance for multiple seasons.
Shop All Star Catcher’s Mitts
All Star makes a mean catcher’s mitt. All Star mitts are designed from the most durable leather for the most serious ballplayers.
Shop Nokona Catcher’s Mitts
Nokona has built its business upon handcrafted, American-made leather gloves. Their catcher’s mitts are no exception.
Shop Rawlings Catcher’s Mitts
Rawlings is the most popular brand of baseball glove used at the Major League level. The top catcher’s mitts made by Rawlings rival any other brand in the game.
Shop Wilson Catcher’s Mitts
You can’t go wrong with Wilson. Whether you grab an A2000 or an A2K, Wilson never fails to deliver.
Only 30 players can be starting MLB catchers, but that doesn’t mean you can’t wear the best catcher's mitt. If you still need help finding a new catcher’s mitt, please don’t hesitate to reach out to us. You can contact our Glove Experts via phone (866-321-4568), email (support@justgloves.com), or LIVE CHAT. We’re JustGloves, and we’re with you from Click to Catch!
Looking for more catcher's gear? Field General is a community for catchers brought to you by the same team behind JustGloves.